Sandro Tonali made his return to football today after a 10-month absence following his involvement in a betting scandal.

Tonali’s return to Newcastle delighted his fans. He was Newcastle United’s ￡53 million crown jewel, a player who had already found success at AC Milan and appeared destined to shine in the Premier League. And shine he did, at least at first. In his debut match against Aston Villa, Tonali not only opened the scoring with a stunning volley but also controlled the game with a presence that belied his age. The chants of “Sandro Tonali, drinks Moretti, eats spaghetti” reverberated through St James’ Park, as the Italian quickly became a fan favourite. His casual dinner at a Wetherspoon pub, of all places, only endeared him more to the Geordie faithful. It seemed Newcastle had found not just a player, but a man who understood the city and its people.

Yet, as the season progressed, Tonali’s performances waned. Rumours of homesickness surfaced, with whispers that the San Siro’s shadow loomed large over his new life in England. The truth, however, was far more complex and troubling. Beneath the surface of Tonali’s struggles lay a secret that would soon shake the football world: he was battling a gambling addiction.

Fall and the fight back

By October, Tonali’s world came crashing down. While on international duty, Italian police investigating an illegal betting ring stormed the national team’s camp and escorted Tonali away. For Newcastle, this was a bolt from the blue. “It was a massive shock,” reflected Dan Ashworth, Newcastle’s sporting director at the time. Tonali had placed bets on matches, including some involving his own team, AC Milan. The fallout was swift and severe: a 10-month worldwide suspension from football, a significant cut to his ￡120,000-a-week wage, and a very public battle with his demons.

Tonali’s admission of guilt and subsequent cooperation with the authorities spared him from a harsher three-year ban. However, the damage was done, and the road to redemption had begun. The midfielder threw himself into his recovery, attending addiction counselling in Milan and training rigorously with Newcastle during his suspension. Despite the setback, Tonali’s resilience shone through. He learned English, integrated into the Newcastle community, and continued to train as if every day were match day.

Challenges ahead

This week, Sandro Tonali has made his long-awaited return in Newcastle’s Carabao Cup match against Nottingham Forest. It was be his first competitive game in 10 months, and all eyes will be on him. Manager of Newcastle United Eddie Howe, who has stood by Tonali throughout this ordeal, is cautiously optimistic. “Physically, he’s very fit, he just needs match sharpness,” Howe remarked. “He’ll be ready to play but he won’t be in his best condition for a month or so.”

Tonali’s return comes at a time when Newcastle finds itself at the crossroads of ambition and morality. The club, now majority-owned by Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund, faces a delicate balance. Gambling, haram in Islam, is banned in Saudi Arabia, yet Newcastle has lucrative partnerships with online betting companies. The irony is stark, and it’s not lost on anyone. Tonali, as part of his punishment, will spend the next eight months making regular trips to Italy, educating fellow players about the dangers of gambling and visiting addiction clinics.

For Newcastle, this is not just about getting a player back on the pitch; it’s about managing the long-term effects of addiction. “I don’t think you conquer an addiction,” Howe wisely noted. “You live with it, so I don’t want to downplay the battle Sandro will have for the rest of his life. But he’s shown real mental strength. I think you’ll eventually see a much stronger person.”

New chapter begins

Tonali’s story is far from over. His return to the pitch is just one step in a long journey of recovery and redemption. The pressure will be immense, not just to perform but to prove that he has learned from his mistakes. Newcastle fans, known for their loyalty, are likely to embrace Tonali once more, but the road ahead is fraught with challenges.

As Tonali warms up before a potential homecoming at St James’ Park, he will do so against a backdrop of flashing betting ads—a stark reminder of the world he’s trying to leave behind. But if there’s one thing this saga has shown, it’s that Sandro Tonali is not just a footballer; he’s a fighter. And in the unforgiving world of professional football, that might just be enough to carry him through.

The coming months will reveal whether Tonali can translate his off-field growth into on-field brilliance. For now, Newcastle waits, hoping that the player they fell in love with can find his way back to them, stronger and wiser than before.

SiGMA East Europe Summit powered by Soft2Bet, happening in Budapest from 2 – 4 September.